The inconsistencies in the six-movie Star Wars story line have been discussed ad nauseum, but here is one problem no one has dealt with as far as I know.* Ben Kenobi’s last words (as a corporeal person) to Luke Skywalker make perfect sense when interpreted within the narrow context of Episode IV, but when viewed through the lens of all six films, they become incomprehensible.
*I didn’t do an exhaustive search on this point, so if I skipped your brilliant analysis, just post a link in the comments.

In the Death Star Command Office, our heroes have overpowered several storm troopers and a gantry officer. R2D2 locates the source of the tractor beam that prevents the Millennium Falcon from leaving. Kenobi leaves to deactive it, but not before this brief exchange with Luke:
BEN: I don’t think you boys can help. I must go alone.
HAN: Whatever you say. I’ve done more than I bargained for on this trip already.
LUKE: I want to go with you.
BEN: Be patient, Luke. Stay and watch over the droids.
LUKE: But he can…
BEN: They must be delivered safely or other star systems will suffer the same fate as Alderaan. Your destiny lies along a different path than mine. The Force will be with you…always!
Here’s the problem. According to Episode III, Kenobi has gone into exile on Tatoonie for the express purpose of keeping an eye on the son of Anakin Skywalker. Near the end of Episode III Kenobi and Yoda discuss their nearly hopeless options:
OBI-WAN: And what of the boy?
YODA: To Tatooine. To his family, send him.
OBI-WAN: I will take the child and watch over him. Master Yoda, do you think Anakin’s twins will be able to defeat Darth Sidious?
YODA: Strong the Force runs, in the Skywalker line. Hope, we can . . . Done, it is. Until the time is right, disappear we will.
By the time Episode IV opens, Kenobi has lived in isolation for nearly twenty years keeping watch over the Most Important Person in the Galaxy, the boy who might have enough natural ability with the Force to defeat Darth Vader and release the galaxy from the iron grip of the Emperor. (Leia, the “other hope” from Episode V was apparently only a dim hope at best.) And yet, Kenobi leaves Luke in the hands of “destiny” as he wanders away to turn off a tractor beam. Does not compute.
The answer to this problem is obvious. George Lucas never had the full, six-film story in mind at any point in the development of the Star Wars saga, despite his consistent claims to have been working on a story too big to film in its enterity in 1976. I’m sure Lucas had a long, general story in mind, but at the level of fine detail, I think he was essentially making it up as he went along. Thus, inconsistencies abound. And for this reason, Star Wars can never be considered the kind of monumental literary success as Lord of the Rings and Dune, multi-episode fantasies with much tighter, consistent story lines.
So let’s rewrite the Command Office scene to make Kenobi’s last words to Luke more consistent with the end of Episode III:
BEN: I don’t think you boys can help. I must go alone.
HAN: Whatever you say. I’ve done more than I bargained for on this trip already.
LUKE I want to go with you.
(Ben gives Luke gives hard stare, then gets right in his face.)
BEN: All right, beotch, listen and listen good. I pissed away twenty of my life in that f***ing desert making sure you didn’t wind up a black spot on a canyon wall because you misjudged your speed in a skyhopper and that you didn’t get your damn head blown off by some drunk with a blaster and good aim.
LUKE: Huh? [Flustered.]
BEN: Shut-up! You’re the only person who can stand up to Darth Vader, which probably means we’re f***ed in the butt big time given your reckless nature.
LUKE: Sorry . . . [Looking at his feet; turning red.]
BEN: You need advanced Jedi training, from either me or Yoda—
LUKE: (softly) Who?
BEN: —otherwise we’re all f***ed, so you follow my instructions. Got it?
LUKE: Okay. [Starting to get choked up.]
BEN: (forcefully) Do not leave this room. I don’t care who knocks on this door or what that stupid robot says to you. Stay here or I swear I will come back and stick my light saber so far up your ignorant butt you’ll need surgery to get it removed. Understand?
LUKE: Geez! Okay! [Really embarrased.]
BEN: Yeah . . . that’s right, beotch. Twenty years in the desert. No way I’m pissing all that away to watch you get blasted by a stormtrooper. Stay here!
(Ben gives the room a hard look, then leaves. Luke slinks over to a corner.)
CHEWBACCA: Growl.
HAN: Dude. You just got owned.
End scene.
Recent Comments